November 17, 2005

  • THURSDAY WHATEVER
    Published on Thursday, November 17, 2005  by CommonDreams.org
    Open Letter to George’s Mama
    by Cindy Sheeha

    Dear Barbara,

    On April 04, 2004, your oldest child killed my oldest child, Casey Austin Sheehan.

    Unlike your oldest child, my son was a marvelous person who joined the military to serve his country and to try and make the world a better place. Casey didn’t want to go to Iraq, but he knew his duty. Your son went AWOL from a glamour unit. George couldn’t even handle the Alabama Air National Guard. Casey joined the Army before your son became commander in chief. We all know that your son was thinking of invading Iraq as early as 1999. Casey was a dead man before George even became president and before he even joined the Army in May of 2000.

    I raised Casey and my other children to use their words to solve problems and conflicts. I told my four children from the time that they were small that it is ALWAYS wrong to kick, bite, hit, scratch, pull hair, etc. If the smaller children couldn’t find the words to solve their conflicts without violence, I always encouraged them to find a mediator like a parent, older sibling, or teacher to help them find the words.

    Did you teach George to use his words and not his violence to solve problems? It doesn’t appear so. Did you teach him that killing other people for profits and oil is ALWAYS wrong? Obviously you did not.  He has lied and he is still lying. Saddam did not have WMDs or ties with al-Qaeda and the Downing Street Memos prove that your son knew this before he invaded Iraq.

    On August 3rd, 2005, your son said that he killed my son and the other brave and honorable Americans for a “noble cause.” Well, Barbara, mother to mother, that angered me. I don’t consider invading and occupying another country that was proven not to be a threat to the USA is a noble cause. I don’t think invading a country, killing its innocent citizens, and ruining the infrastructure to make your family and your family-friendly war profiteers rich is a noble cause.

    So I went down to Crawford in August to ask your son what noble cause did he kill my son for. He wouldn’t speak with me. I think that showed incredibly bad manners. Do you think a president, even if it is your son, should be so inaccessible to his employers? Especially one of his bosses whose life George has devastated so completely?

    I have been to the White House several times since August to try and meet with George and I am going back to Crawford next week. Do you think you can call him and ask him to do the right thing and bring the troops home from this illegal and immoral war in Iraq that he carelessly started? I hear you are one of the few people he still talks to. He won’t speak to his father, who knew the difficulties and impossibilities of going into Iraq and that’s why he didn’t go there in the first Gulf War. If you won’t tell him to bring the troops home, can you at least urge him to meet with me?

    You said this in 2003, a little over a year before my dear, sweet Casey was killed by your son’s policies:

    “Why should we hear about body bags and deaths? Oh, I mean, it’s not relevant. So why should I waste my beautiful mind on something like that?” (Good Morning America, March 18, 2003)

    Now I have something to tell you, Barbara. I didn’t want to hear about deaths or body bags either. On April 04, 2004, three Army officers came to my house to tell me that Casey was killed in Iraq. I fell on the floor screaming and begging the cruel Angel of Death to take me too. But the Angel of Death that took my son is your son.

    Casey came home in a flag draped coffin on April 10th. I used to have a beautiful mind too. Now my mind is filled with images of seeing his beautiful body in his casket and memories of burying my brave and honest boy before his life really began. Casey’s beautiful mind was ended by an insurgent’s bullet to his brain, but your son might as well have pulled the trigger.

    Besides encouraging your son to have some honesty and courage and to finally do the right thing, don’t you think you owe me and every other Gold Star parent an apology for that cruel and careless remark you made?

    Your son’s amazingly ignorant, arrogant, and reckless policies in Iraq are responsible for so much sorrow and trouble in this world.

    Can you make him stop? Do it before more mothers’ lives are needlessly and cruelly harmed. There have been too many worldwide already.

    Sincerely,

    Cindy Sheehan
    Mother of Casey Sheehan
    Founder and President of Gold Star Families for Peace
    Founder of Camp Casey Peace Foundation


    Deep Thought:  “Before a mad scientist goes mad, there’s probably a time when he’s only partially mad. And this is the time when he’s going to throw his best parties.”
    Today I am grateful for:  The ability to back up
    Guess the Movie:  “California, tell your people to stay away. Stay away now, don’t – don’t come in here. Whatever you hear, stay away! John Doe has the upper hand!” Answer: Se7en, 1995. Winner: tearsign.
     Leading House Democrat Urges Withdrawal From Iraq

    “It is Time to Bring Them Home”
     WASHINGTON – A leading pro-defense Democrat in the House of Representatives on Thursday urged the Bush administration to start the immediate withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq.
    Senior Democrat Rep. John Murtha is calling for the immediate withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq.
    “The U.S. cannot accomplish anything further in Iraq militarily. It is time to bring them home,” said Rep. John Murtha of Pennsylvania, a senior Democrat on the subcommittee that oversees military spending.   (Rest of article here.)

Comments (12)

  • Quite a mighty statement from one mother to another!

  • Wow. I’d like to think the letter would help but the conservative marketing/propaganda machine seems to know the playing field well enough to minimize it.
    Movie: Se7en

  • Correctomundo – even spelled it right. And I know what you mean about minimizing the letter. I’m just appreciative that she’s hanging in there for the rest of us.

  • Read the letter, but more powerful then any one mother’s voice will be a chorus of persistent and insistent protests of many many mothers, I also think the slick marketing machinerythat seeks to quiet the protests ,or render them useless may become less effective over time… we are all after all capable of learning….we are not stupid…

  • I wish I thought that would make a difference. I wish I thought Barbara Bush might actually see it. I wish I thought that if she saw it she would not put on her “let them eat cake” attitude that she has shown so often. I wish I thought all of those things. Unfortunately, I do not.

  • I was reading her wonderful letter from my subs list so when I clicked to comment her picture came up.  Wow.  She packs a wallop.  That’s a powerful heart she’s got.

  • When I read this, I’m reminded that everyone has a Mother, even Sadam. In saddness and extreme grief, this lady blamed George’s mother. However, we should blame the one who is really causing all of this, and our inability to fight him. Without the help of love for one another, which Jesus teaches, we become trapped and do the will of the adversary.

  • I saw this editorial and thought of her letter.  In it Anna Quinlin says that the Bush’s didn’t intend for this war to be personal.  Isn’t that the way dictators and leaders get us to fight any war? We forget about the people in it and remain fast to the glorious cause that was fabricated.  I DO blame George’s mother for raising an inhumane child and giving him plenty of inherited weath with no morals and no empathy to go with it.   http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/9785746/site/newsweek/

  • I am totally anti Bush and against the war. But this letter, and a lot of what she does, just sits funny with me. I keep thinking of her poor son and why he joined the military to begin with. I wish she’d kept him out, yelled and screamed and not let him join. Sure, this is a stupid war. It makes me sick, too. But military men and women get killed all the time for stupid reasons. Like some training exercise goes wrong….talk about a meaningless way to die. Sometimes I wonder if we could talk to his ghost, if he’d be embarassed. I feel so mixed about this. I agree with her anti-war sentiment, but in some ways, I think she dishonors his memory. I dunno. I’m afraid I’m coming across harsh, or FOX TV conservative, which I don’t intend. It’s just every military person I have ever talked to, they feel such pride. I guess the dead ones can’t talk.

  • I thank God I personally did not have to raise a son or daughter for 18 years to sacrifice to war. But I think that this letter signifies how many feel about Bush’s War. Judi

  • Cindy Sheehan is one of the greatest of American heroes.

  • i know you didn’t write this letter, but thanks for sharing it. it’s brilliant.

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *